Is paying the same influencers month after month really worth it?
Influencer marketing has become a global strategy across cities like New York, London, Toronto, Berlin, and Nairobi. But after the fifth, seventh, or even tenth time the same influencer mentions your product... does your audience still care?
We analyzed the influencer marketing strategies of 10 fast-growing companies in the ecommerce, SaaS, and lifestyle spaces. Each of them pays over 200 influencers every single month.
What We Found Over a 12-Month Period
Here’s where things get interesting: while short-term ROI was strong in the first 90 days, the return on repeated influencer partnerships began to decline after month four. However, some companies still came out ahead by doubling down—here’s why:
- Familiarity builds credibility: In key regions like California, Ontario, and Western Europe, customers trusted products more when influencers mentioned them regularly.
- SEO impact: Repeated mentions and backlinks from influencer content improved domain authority and rankings—especially with location-based keywords.
- Brand lift vs. direct sales: ROI didn’t always show in immediate conversions, but post-campaign surveys revealed significant growth in brand recall after six months.
So Should You Keep Paying the Same Influencers?
✅ YES — if:
- You’re building a long-term brand in competitive markets (like New York, Berlin, Mumbai).
- The influencer’s audience matches your target GEO region and intent.
- You’re using them for both conversions and emotional branding.
❌ NO — if:
- You only care about short-term click-based ROI.
- The influencer’s engagement is clearly dropping.
- Your product has hit its peak exposure in their audience.
Pro Tip: Rotate Influencers Like Ad Placements
Think of your influencer strategy like a media schedule. Run one influencer for 3–4 months, pause, then reintroduce them with a new angle or product. This keeps audiences engaged and prevents fatigue.
This method has helped brands grow consistently across cities like Sydney, Paris, and Lagos.
Key Takeaway
Don’t just pay influencers for reach—pay for timing, location, and message clarity.
Before you renew that contract, ask yourself:
“Is this influencer still helping us grow the brand in the right cities, with the right people, at the right time?”
Want to Scale Your Influencer ROI by City?
We help brands grow using GEO + SEO + influencer layering strategies that target the *right people in the right places*. Whether you're launching in Europe, East Africa, North America, or Asia, we’ll help you use influencers like a performance channel—not a gamble.
Book Your Free Influencer Growth Strategy Call
MarketWorth — Building Brands That Outlive the Scroll.
Comments